Homemade with Love
The Taste of Home, Baked Just for You.
Handmade hand pies crafted from scratch in New York — because the best things are always made with love.
#1 Pie Crust in America - Grandma
As Seen in
Martha Stewart · Hudson Valley Magazine .Westchester Magazine
Strawberry
S’mores
Wild Berry
Apple Pie
“Best sweet treat ever! Literally as soon as I tried I knew I’d be hooked! Brough all my friends and family to try because I knew they would be too. Low and behold, they are!”
— Alexa AmatoWhat People Are Saying
“Sweetie Pies is ALWAYS fresh and you can taste the love put into every cookie or pie! The flavors are fun and match my mood for every season”
— Shea Decaro“Always the absolute best! Delicious, unique, and a crowd favorite!”
— Kelsey Denninger“Sweetie pies have the best tarts I've ever had! Such fun and tasty flavors!”
—Amber Lopez“Amazing, I love the variety and always the freshness!
— Northern Westchester Moms 
Sweetie Pies Minis
Sweetie Pies also come in a mini size.
These minis are perfect for a dessert table at your next event or a fun bite sized treat!
Sweetie Buns
Soft and fluffy cinnamon roll, topped with a scrumptious cream cheese icing.
Chocolate Brownies
Decadent, homemade brownies that are baked with rich chocolate. Each brownie box comes with every part of the brownie, edges, and all. Crispy edges with gooey centers that will delight any chocolate lover.
Chocolate Chip Cookies
These homemade, soft baked chocolate chip cookies are the perfect side to your Sweetie Pies.
The cookies are made in small batches and, just like the Sweetie Pies, made from scratch with organic ingredients.
These cookies have a slight chewy texture on the edges with a soft center, bringing just enough sweetness to every bite.
Want to stay updated on Sweetie Pie events, exclusive updates and offers? Click below to stay in the loop and get 10% off your first order!